Ian Rankin's Fleshmarket Alley

What better time to read Ian Rankin’s latest novel than the early days of the new year? Crack open a can of Slim Fast and settle back with a good book.
Fleshmarket Alley is a John Rebus novel; if you’re a Rebus fan, you know what to expect by now. Those readers new to the series shouldn’t be daunted.

The discovery of skeletal remains in an Edinburgh alley comes on the same day as a violent murder in a housing project known as Knoxland. Siobhan Clarke, Rebus’ sidekick, is assigned to the skeletons; she’s also concerned about a missing girl, the sister of a rape victim who subsequently killed herself.
These events form the book’s principle threads; when it’s learned that the skeletons were stolen from the forensics lab at a local university, the cops can only scratch their heads. Rebus is more concerned about the stabbing death of a Turkish journalist. The victim’s family lives in official limbo at a detetention center, where asylum seekers are held awaiting disposition of their status as political refugees.

Gradually the novel’s many threads are woven together in a skillful narrative; if Ian Rankin has an axe to grind about the UK’s immigration practices, that’s okay, but the author intrusion threatens to sink the narrative flow of the novel. The line between social criticism and telling a good story is often ignored by writers seeking to persuade readers to a point of view. Charles Dickens was a master at this technique; I can’t think of many authors who’ve pulled it off recently.

The plot’s complexity heightens a sense of moody elegance that infuses the story. Each revelation exposes the characters to uncomfortable truths about racism, bureaucracy, and the faceless victims of exploitation. At times the reader might feel they’ve won a trip to Ottawa in mid-January; it’s gray and cold, and the prospect of spring thaw seems distant. Rebus and Siobhan clear their cases, brush closer to one another than in the past, but the world weary duo lack the energy of previous novels.

Ian Rankin is certainly one of the better crime fiction writers working today. Fleshmarket Alley is a good book, more introspective than most, and well-written. It will be interesting to see where he takes Rebus and Siobhan after this one.

About the author

Jeff Grim

Jeff Grim has been a reader all of his life. He has had a particular interest in military history, any war at any time. His fascination with military history has brought him to an interest in historical fiction where the history comes alive with fictitious heroes and villains. Recently, Jeff has become interested in historical mysteries set in various time periods.

View all posts

1 Comment

  • The latest Detective Inspector John Rebus novel
    is Rankin’s most political and speaks to racism, bigotry, slave labor, smuggling human beings and the heartless ways these poor souls are used as mules for drug dealers. They are referred to as “asylum seekers” but are housed in a former prison under the most horrendous circumstances. Rankin is speaking out about “white” Scotland, and the darker skinned people who are knocking on her door … but are not wanted there.

    “The people who don’t fit in, the people who are forced to play the role of outsiders. ‘I think Scotland was complacent for many years: we don’t have room for racism, we’re too busy with bigotry.’ But this is just not the case” says lawyer activist Birwan … because racism has made its insidious way into the fabric of the culture.

    The murder of a newspaper man who brought his small family to Scotland to find a new home sets a powder keg under the authorities who keep these people locked up in an old prison.

    Fans will love this intellectually challenging novel and the new level of John Rebus’s self examination.

    ENJOY
    BARBARA LIPKIEN GERSHENBAUM