Comments on: Discussion of Narnia Movie http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/ seemingly random thoughts on books & ideas Thu, 17 May 2012 14:12:15 -0400 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.2 By: Phil http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-639 Phil Thu, 12 May 2005 17:30:13 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-639 Redding, I understand that they currently plan to make a film of all the books. If the first one goes well, they will do another or two, and if those are well received, they will continue. I believe the Christian themes will remain in this coming film, unless they write a few lines to try to neutralize them; but I don't expect it. Maybe in another film. Redding, I understand that they currently plan to make a film of all the books. If the first one goes well, they will do another or two, and if those are well received, they will continue. I believe the Christian themes will remain in this coming film, unless they write a few lines to try to neutralize them; but I don’t expect it. Maybe in another film.

]]> By: redding http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-638 redding Thu, 12 May 2005 12:34:33 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-638 they better keep in the link to christianity otherwise it would not be a true chronicle of Narnia. One more thing- are they going to ever make the first book in the narnia series into a movie (the magicians nephew i think) because that was my fav story they better keep in the link to christianity otherwise it would not be a true chronicle of Narnia. One more thing- are they going to ever make the first book in the narnia series into a movie (the magicians nephew i think) because that was my fav story

]]> By: amcorrea http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-637 amcorrea Fri, 06 May 2005 04:35:18 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-637 P.S. My irritation is directed at the issue at large--not your particular comment. P.S. My irritation is directed at the issue at large–not your particular comment.

]]> By: amcorrea http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-636 amcorrea Fri, 06 May 2005 04:29:58 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-636 This is the only idea Hollywood cares about: $$$. Granted, "the powers that be" want to strike the right "balance" in order to hit paydirt. Their anxiety on this point can only amuse, not seriously provoke. What bothers me is the assumption that The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is full of "controversial ideas." If a studio exec read the novel without knowing anything about it, I seriously doubt there would be any concern about "controversy." But alas, "controversy" has been superimposed over it and it can no longer speak for itself. Incidentally, Maud made an interesting point back in February: <a href="http://maudnewton.com/blog/index.php?p=4819" rel="nofollow">http://maudnewton.com/blog/index.php?p=4819</a> This is the only idea Hollywood cares about: $$$. Granted, “the powers that be” want to strike the right “balance” in order to hit paydirt. Their anxiety on this point can only amuse, not seriously provoke.

What bothers me is the assumption that The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is full of “controversial ideas.” If a studio exec read the novel without knowing anything about it, I seriously doubt there would be any concern about “controversy.” But alas, “controversy” has been superimposed over it and it can no longer speak for itself.

Incidentally, Maud made an interesting point back in February: http://maudnewton.com/blog/index.php?p=4819

]]> By: phil http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-635 phil Fri, 06 May 2005 03:13:43 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-635 I may agree with you, Amcorrea. If they focused on the story instead of the appeal, they may overcome the critics and gain the audience they want; but all deep stories touch on controversial ideas, especially when Hollywood is deadset against certain ideas. So I understand why directors, producers, and screenwriters would think about how their story works into whatever controversy is perceived. Kevin, you're right about the purists and even non-purist fans. Some stories must not be tampered with, if you want anyone to watch it. But with this story, I think the press are the ones making much ado about the story ideas, not the moviemakers. I may agree with you, Amcorrea. If they focused on the story instead of the appeal, they may overcome the critics and gain the audience they want; but all deep stories touch on controversial ideas, especially when Hollywood is deadset against certain ideas. So I understand why directors, producers, and screenwriters would think about how their story works into whatever controversy is perceived.

Kevin, you’re right about the purists and even non-purist fans. Some stories must not be tampered with, if you want anyone to watch it. But with this story, I think the press are the ones making much ado about the story ideas, not the moviemakers.

]]> By: amcorrea http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-634 amcorrea Fri, 06 May 2005 00:19:58 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-634 I think they should just shut up with all the "sacred" vs. "secular" lingo and focus on the story. If the goal is to stay true to the novel, then the audience will be there. It frustrates me that this film is already carrying so much baggage out of the gate. To me the "spiritual issues" question is a non-issue if they just remain faithful to the story. Those who want to see "themes" will, and those who don't won't. They weren't put there as Christian propaganda to "indoctrinate" the masses. I think they should just shut up with all the “sacred” vs. “secular” lingo and focus on the story. If the goal is to stay true to the novel, then the audience will be there. It frustrates me that this film is already carrying so much baggage out of the gate. To me the “spiritual issues” question is a non-issue if they just remain faithful to the story. Those who want to see “themes” will, and those who don’t won’t. They weren’t put there as Christian propaganda to “indoctrinate” the masses.

]]> By: Kevin Holtsberry http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/comment-page-1/#comment-633 Kevin Holtsberry Thu, 05 May 2005 22:53:55 +0000 http://collectedmiscellany.com/2005/05/discussion-of-narnia-movie/#comment-633 Phil, I think few in Hollywood think about turning off spiritual minded people these days, but perhaps things are changing. With Narnia, I think the issue is how to make it attractive to a broad range audience without upsetting purist fans, sort of like with LOTR but with a spiritual dimension. What I think this point misses is that a movie can just appeal to spiritual minded people and be a blockbuster. There are a lot of people in America interested in spiritual issues. Phil,

I think few in Hollywood think about turning off spiritual minded people these days, but perhaps things are changing. With Narnia, I think the issue is how to make it attractive to a broad range audience without upsetting purist fans, sort of like with LOTR but with a spiritual dimension.

What I think this point misses is that a movie can just appeal to spiritual minded people and be a blockbuster. There are a lot of people in America interested in spiritual issues.

]]>