Jan 21 2009
The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Civil War by H.W. Crocker III
Kevin asked whether I wanted to read and review H.W. Crocker’s The Politically Incorrect Guide to the Civil War. I said I would, but I was not quite sure what I was getting myself into.
Let me get the basics over with first. The book is 337 pages. It is divided into five parts that are entitled: Why the South Was Right; The History of the War in Sixteen Battles You Should Know; Eminent Civil War Generals; Call in the Cavalry; and Beating Retreat. These parts are then further divided into various chapters.
Obviously, based upon the title of the first part (Why the South Was Right), Crocker is a Southern apologist. Being a Yankee, this does not bother me because I at least know where he is coming from. He brings forth some of the same worn out reasons for defending the South – mainly that the war was for state’s rights and not slavery. Initially, that may have been the case for most people on both sides, but that was quickly changed once Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation (it was not a matter of how the Proclamation was to be enforced, but how it was perceived – this was the main reason why the French and British shied away from supporting the Confederacy).









