Reviews

Richard Peck on Okay For Now

After I posted my take on Gary D. Schmidt’s Okay For Now, some guy named Richard Peck decided to post his review at some tabloid or something …

OK, OK, Richard Peck  is an award winning author not just some guy.

Anywho, he has an interesting take on the book. He admits the plot is full to the point of breaking the plausibility isn’t always the hightest but, like me, in the end he couldn’t help but love the book.

Happily, Doug lives in a world where an unhappy boy in desperate need of guidance is passed from one nurturing adult to the next, beginning with the elderly librarian, Mr. Powell, who reaches past Doug’s defenses to teach him how to draw the birds that have moved him so. Meanwhile, as Doug studies “Jane Eyre” in English class, Charlotte Brontë’s diction begins to seep into his vocabulary, just as Audubon’s birds seep into his soul. Next he takes up Aaron Copland. This is a kid who once counted as his sole hero the Yankees’ Joe Pepitone.

“Okay for Now” is crowded with more incident and empowerment than any eighth-grade year or novel can quite contain. Events stretch credulity. At one point, Doug turns up briefly on the Broadway stage, playing a female role, no less. But Schmidt is a master of the unlikely.

[...]

I read it all through misting eyes. Flirting with despair on its way to affirmation, “Okay for Now” is about how one kid, among legions, has to reach beyond his family for help from the other adults in his life to give him a hand.

I think this is one of those books where authorial skill and the power of the story overcome any weaknesses in plot. So yeah, Richard Peck agrees with me.

 

Okay for Now by Gary D. Schmidt

I read the companion novel to Gary D. Schmidt‘s Okay for Now just because I like to read things in order. But once I had read The Wednesday Wars (TWW) I was worried that the expectations that excellent book set up would be too high for this recent release. I was wrong.

I enjoyed Okay for Now a great deal. It is similar to TWW in many ways, and connected through a shared character,  but is different enough to stand on its own and shine.

Here is the Publishers synopsis:

“The Dump” is what Doug Swieteck calls his new home in upstate New York. He lands there in the summer of 1968, when the Apollo space missions are under way, Joe Pepitone is slugging for the New York Yankees, and the Vietnam War is raging. At home he lives with a father who has lost his way and a brother accused of robbery. And Doug’s oldest brother is returning from Vietnam. Who knows what wounds his missions have given him?

But Doug has his own mission, too, and it begins when he first sees the plates of John James Audubon’s Birds of America at the local library. His mission will lead him to Lil Spicer, who shows him how to drink a really cold Coke, to Mrs. Windermere, who drags him to a theater opening, and to the customers of his Saturday grocery deliveries, who together will open a world as strange to him as the lunar landscape.

Two books in an I am a big Gary D. Schmidt fan.

Keep Reading

The Wednesday Wars by Gary Schmidt

Cover of "The Wednesday Wars"

Cover of The Wednesday Wars

Every once in a while I am prompted by Twitter to read a book. Obviously there is an endless stream of books recommended by publishers, bloggers and readers, but sometimes a book catches my eye and the discussion on Twitter prompts me to check it out.

This is how I stumbled on the work of Gary D. Schmidt. Everyone was talking about his new book Okay for Now and when I went to check it out it seemed very much in my wheelhouse.  But I thought it would be worth it to check out the prior book of which OFN is sort of a spin off.  So I grabbed The Wednesday Wars from the library and started reading.

It turned out to be a great book.  Just a wonderful story full of great characters, powerful emotions and quite a bit of wisdom. This is an example of what young adult writing can be – literature to my mind.

It offers a great coming of age story but also explores growing up on Long Island in the late sixties and what that era – the time, place and events that made it up – might have meant to junior high students and the adults around them.

Keep Reading

Lion of Liberty: Patrick Henry and the Call to a New Nation by Harlow Giles Unger

Continuing with my meanderings in history – I thought the next subject I would look into was our founding fathers.  There are so many and much ink has been spilled analyzing each phrase and aspect of their lives.

So, I veered away from Washington, Jefferson, and Adams and choose to read about Patrick Henry – Patrick “Give me Liberty or give me Death” Henry.  Harlow Giles Unger provides a light and refreshing read of Henry’s life in Lion of Liberty: Patrick Henry and the Call to a New Nation.

Here is a brief description of the book from its inside cover:

In this action-packed history, award-winning author Harlow Giles Unger unfolds the epic story of Patrick Henry, who roused Americans to fight government tyranny—both British and American. Remembered largely for his cry for “liberty or death,” Henry was actually the first (and most colorful) of America’s Founding Fathers—first to call Americans to arms against Britain, first to demand a bill of rights, and first to fight the growth of big government after the Revolution.  As quick with a rifle as he was with his tongue, Henry was America’s greatest orator and courtroom lawyer, who mixed histrionics and hilarity to provoke tears or laughter from judges and jurors alike. Henry’s passion for liberty (as well as his very large family), suggested to many Americans that he, not Washington, was the real father of his country.

This biography is history at its best, telling a story both human and philosophical. As Unger points out, Henry’s words continue to echo across America and inspire millions to fight government intrusion in their daily lives.

This book has helped me understand more about the political battles that were fought during the Continental and Confederation Congresses.  I did not realize how much animosity there was toward the delegates who wrote the Constitution – our country was on the verge of a civil war over states rights against federal control (similar to what occurred 70 some years later).  As Unger points out, Henry was at the forefront of the Antifederalists in their quest to limit the authority of the federal government.  Unger captures Henry’s passion for states rights.

It is interesting to note (as Unger highlights) that the British oligarchy was replaced by an American one – many of our founding fathers were wealthy men who wanted to control the direction our country was headed.  According to Unger, these men were more interested in keeping their own power than giving more power to the common man.  I do not know enough about our founding fathers to have an opinion beyond the basics that I am glad the America won its independence, but it does make one think about the real winners of the American Revolution – was it the aristocratic elite or the average American who benefited the most from the Revolution?

Al Qaeda and What It Means to Be Modern by John Gray

Cover of "Al Qaeda and What it Means to b...

Cover of Al Qaeda and What it Means to be Modern

Let’s face it, I can be a lazy and discursive blogger/reviewer at times. I frequently start my reviews with some multiple paragraph explanation of how I came to read the book in question or some point only tangentially related to the review. And I often steal the plot summary or review from some other source.

I am afraid this is one of those times.

The reason I often steal book summaries is that I am jealous of their ability to capture something about a book in so few words.  A prime example is the Kirkus review of Al Qaeda and What It Means to Be Modern:

A smart, learned, lucid, and alarming argument, occasionally overstated for rhetorical purposes.

A one sentence review that manages to capture my thoughts just about exactly. Yes, I am jealous. Keep Reading